Aesthetic finishes on stainless steel tubing
Aesthetic finishes on stainless steel tubing
Applications vary widely for stainless steel and nickel alloy tubing and in turn, aesthetic requirements are similarly wide ranging. It’s important to note that when discussing appearance, measured surface finish (using contact profilometry or optical interferometry tools) is not the same as aesthetic finish.
A typical measured finish on the outside of a cold drawn (welded or seamless) tube at small diameters is 16 Ra microinches or better. The lower the value, the fewer peaks and valleys on the surface of the tube and the “smoother” the tube surface. Measured surface finish is critical in applications where minimizing friction is important---say two tubes sliding against each other with minimal gap between them. Or, in another example, maintaining a laminar flow for fluids flowing around the tube in a manifold or medical device---rougher surfaces create turbulent flow.
Switching back to aesthetic finishes, these differ from measured finishes because what matters is how the tube looks. A tube could have a relatively poor measured finish but an excellent appearance and vice versa. Tubes with high-end aesthetic appearance normally have a bright and polished appearance. Such aesthetic finishes can be achieved by means including centerless grinding, mechanical polishing (using custom built machinery), or electropolishing/micropolishing. Electropolish and micropolish are typically reserved for cut or fabricated tubes, because these methods are relatively expensive and normally introduced near the end of the fabrication sequence. For grinding and polishing, different types of wheels with finer or coarser grits can be used to achieve the desired finish.
If reflectivity is an important characteristic, it’s crucial to pass that information along when requesting a quotation. Samples are extremely helpful when establishing an aesthetic standard for a product. Use of metrology cameras with algorithms that can evaluate product against a known standard are tremendously helpful to turn a traditionally subjective measurement into one that can be measured objectively.
Reasons for lower end tube appearances can include:
- Cleanliness / residues (most raw material is not sold ultrasonically clean unless requested).
- Considerable cold work with sufficient intermediate heat treating, which can increase the grain size, giving the tube a grainy appearance.
- Scratches from the drawing process if there are die imperfections or debris
- Light scratches from the straightening process, which are typical but for the discerning application objectionable.
The good news is that many of these appearances can be improved, or prevented entirely if clear expectations are established between the customer and manufacturer at the start.
If you’re not sure where to start, some questions to consider with your engineering team (not an all inclusive list):
- Are there any areas of the product where finish might impact the end use?
- Is the tube entirely concealed from the end user or is it exposed and therefore visible?
- If it’s visible, is it being used in an application with a high default expectation for appearance (medical/dental) or one with generally a lower standard (industrial applications).
Finally, a decent place to start is looking at aesthetic finish standards established for rolled stainless steel strip and sheet. The strip industry uses a number system from 1 to 8, where 1 represents hot rolled, rough matte sheet through number 8 which is a fully buffed mirror like finish with reflectivity values close to that of a true mirror.
